A public forum really is a scary place.
I was thinking about this the other day. Earlier this week,
The Boxcar Voices had our event scheduled for Thursday (two days ago) at a local coffee shop. The theme of our event was "Awkward Ever-Afters and Unhappy Endings." We did the same event last summer, and it was one of our biggest events. Juliann and myself designed the event so that people could share awkward love stories.
Once the evening arrived, it quickly became awkward sex stories.
 |
| On the prowl... |
I told one about an interesting interaction I had with a cougar (the social phenomenon, not the large cat... or maybe both). There were stories of revenant Subway sandwiches, barn yard shenanigans (not told from the first person), and something pertaining to trailer parks I can't quite remember.
Needless to say, the content was more than questionable. It actually wasn't a question at all: it was hard fact.
So I'm thinking about this three days out from the next event that's going to be held in a public coffee shop. See, the last event was held in a local underground theatre where, in the name of art, relatively anything goes. It's also a place where people don't just amble in for a cup of coffee and conversation. It didn't occur to me that the same material might be questionable in a place that was so open -- where the audience would be wider. Now I'm worried because
1. What if we piss off the owner of the coffee shop? Loss of venue, loss of credibility, and the show might get shut down mid-flow.
2. What if we piss off the wrong clientele? Loss of credibility. Bad publicity. Our event becomes seen as vulgar and obscene... which is okay, but I'd like to keep it classy for the most part.
3. Where the hell can I find another venue in 72 hours? There are 7 venues in Florence: three bars, a coffee shop, a record store, a theatre, and a library. Slim pickin's
I called the owner and expressed my concern. He, obviously in best interest of his business and moral values, agreed that it might be a problem, and he just didn't feel comfortable with it. I'd like to make it very clear that I hold no contempt for his decision, and that I would have probably done the exact same thing given the town we are in. If this was Chicago or, hell, even Birmingham, I would expect it to be different.
I say the disclaimer to justify the tapestry of expletives I wove in my head as I hung-up the phone. So I called the theatre and the only day they could do it was Friday (last night), and I had to work.
Long story long, I had to miss the event that I was a part of.
This raises an interesting question about public space.
It's a scary thing to get up on stage and
express yourself. Whether you are playing music, reading poetry, dancing, or acting, it's nerve-wracking throwing your entire being in front of people. They will either love you and applaud, hate it and applaud, scream in anger and disgust, or be very quiet. I think the last one is probably the worst.
And what about the audience? Should the audience be open and receptive? I think so. And I think that is very hard to find (especially in this area, but anywhere really). There are going to be those that sit through an entire show with arms crossed, leg bouncing, tongue nervously rubbing across chapped lips, eyes glancing around the room with a
I can't believe he just said that. Did you hear that? Why are you laughing, that wasn't funny!

I don't think a writer should try to please an audience. I think one should write for an audience, but an audience is created by pleasing some and displeasing others. A lot of others.
I think it is vital that a stage should be had for people to be pleased and displeased. But more than that, I think the audience needs to be open.
Not open and accepting. You shouldn't accept everything you come across. If it goes against who you are, by all means push it away. But at least be open to listening and understanding. Until then, no one has any right to judge.
I think it brings up more questions about free speech, but I'll get into those later on.